The New Scarlet Letter Is "H"

Marginalize, privatize, anathematize: These are the successive goals of gay-marriage advocates when it comes to their opponents.

First, ignore the arguments of traditional marriage’s defenders, that marriage has always existed in order to bring men and women together so that children will have mothers and fathers, and that same-sex marriage is not an expansion but a dismantling of the institution. Instead, assert that no rational arguments along these lines even exist and so no refutation is necessary, and insinuate that those who merely want to defend marriage are “anti-gay thugs” or “theocrats” or “Taliban,” as some critics have said.

Second, drive the wedge between faith and reason, chasing traditional religious arguments on marriage and morality underground, as private forms of irrationality.

Finally, decree the victory of the new public morality – here the judges have their role in the liberal strategy – and read the opponents of the new dispensation out of polite society, as the crazed bigots of our day.

via Kevin DeYoung

Tags: Notes
posted 1 / 6 / 2011
  1. bunkercomplex likes this
  2. peterwknox likes this
  3. pasionglenn reblogged this from sds
  4. mjent likes this
  5. sendmelies likes this
  6. melanyouth reblogged this from squashed and added:
    (via squashed):
  7. resurrecthobbes likes this
  8. ilyagerner likes this
  9. azspot likes this
  10. svennysvensven likes this
  11. theomnibusoctopus likes this
  12. mynameisconnor likes this
  13. sealyhamish likes this
  14. terenceinmonochrome likes this
  15. dominiquejames likes this
  16. kquizzo17 likes this
  17. apsies likes this
  18. mar-see-ah likes this
  19. notthebarefootcontessa reblogged this from squashed
  20. notthebarefootcontessa likes this
  21. michi64 likes this
  22. squashed reblogged this from sds and added:
    SDS, Daniel Holter, and Matthew J. Franck disagree on marriage equality. Franck accuses marriage equality proponents of...
  23. apoplecticskeptic likes this
  24. ashapelessform likes this
  25. vincetherestillthere reblogged this from sds and added:
  26. vincetherestillthere likes this
  27. sds reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic and added:
    Daniel Holter responded to my post about the way gay marriage advocates approach the debate with traditional marriage...
  28. ultralaser likes this
  29. breathelara likes this
  30. nailtipflips likes this
  31. voxlupus reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic and added:
    And here’s my two cents: Honestly. If you’re going to say that gay people shouldn’t be married, make the same argument...
  32. warholesque likes this
  33. androyd5 likes this
  34. writingitout reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic and added:
    I think the worst argument about ‘traditional’ marriage is the traditional part. Marriage was not about love or even...
  35. bostongrits likes this
  36. lauraleonard likes this
  37. l3fan-0-rama likes this
  38. mkhall likes this
  39. mashamoshpit reblogged this from sds
  40. finding-joy likes this
  41. sawyeriii likes this
  42. purtycamel likes this
  43. aatombomb likes this
  44. iwillnotsuckyou likes this
  45. permanentsix likes this
  46. tlbb reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic and added:
    Thank you, Daniel.
  47. myladyingrey reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  48. myladyingrey likes this
  49. apoplecticskeptic reblogged this from sds and added:
    Speaking as an amateur advocate for marriage equality (I’m not a fan of the term “gay marriage,” since I believe that’s...
  50. gogallop said: Most proponents of gay marriage aren’t out to do anything to their opponents. They just want to overcome obstacles to their own happiness, like heterosexuals and marriage traditionalists.
blog comments powered by Disqus